Oct 31, 2011


Over the years American Generals and Admirals, certainly those on the joint chiefs of staff, were less ready to go to battle or war than their civilian superiors. They saw all the drawbacks, inadequacy of forces, unacceptable casualty expectations, difficult logistics, disbelief that their civilian superiors would permit them to do everything necessary for victory. This is not only a recent phenomenon.

During the American Civil War (1861-5) Pres. Lincoln suffered from the disinclination of his northern generals to attack rather than stay in their defensive positions. Once he wrote to one of his commanding generals, “If you will not be needing the army over the weekend, I should like to borrow it.”

When he finally found in Ulysses S. Grant, a general who was prepared to attack, others complained that Grant was a drunkard. Lincoln responded, “Tell me what he drinks so I can send cases of it to my other generals.”

For many years, Israeli generals were considered the opposite, more ready to go into battle than their civilian governments. When Prime Minister Levi Eshkol hesitated on the eve of the Six Day War, Ezer Weizman tore off his epaulets and threw them on the floor in disgust.

In 1976 the IDF conceived and carried out the daring Entebbe raid, rescuing over a hundred Israeli and Jewish hostages of an Air France flight kidnapped by bloodthirsty terrorists who threatened to kill them one by one. They didn’t tell Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin that the mission was impossible and he had no choice but to negotiate with the terrorists. They gave him a plan and carried it out brilliantly.

In 1981 when Saddam Hussein’s Osirak nuclear reactor threatened Israel with atomic destruction, the IDF did not tell Prime Minister Menachem Begin that it was impossible to overfly so many Arab countries to reach the target at the extreme limit of the air force’s capability. They made a plan and carried it out.

But in recent years something has changed. In the Second Lebanon War the senior officers commanded from behind their plasma screens instead at the fore with the famous rallying cry, “Follow me!” Second rate officers turned excellent soldiers into second rate troops with second rate results.

Military doctrines which failed for the Americans in various parts of the world were adopted by the IDF and failed here too. Zero casualties became the main aim of military actions, which immediately put victory out of grasp.

Thus for over five years the IDF did not give successive Israeli governments a military option to free Gilad Schalit. Either they were “eyeless in Gaza” or they were afraid of casualties in an action, or both.

Paradoxically, during this time the U.S. armed forces carried out an “Israeli style” raid in Pakistan to eliminate Osama bin Laden.

Junior and middle range Israeli officers, many of them wearers of knitted kipot, are as good or better than ever, but the IDF General Staff needs to reverse its “Americanization.”


  1. Yitz, great post. It's a dangerous trend. No doubt the frequent law suits and arrests against those, including soldiers, for self-defense has badly influenced the IDF. Are you acquainted with Honenu? If not, please give me a call.

  2. I drop a leave a response whenever ӏ аppreciate a article on а site
    or іf I havе somеthing tο νaluable tо
    contгibute to the diѕcussion. Usually it's triggered by the fire displayed in the article I looked at. And after this post "THE AMERICANIZATION OF THE IDF GENERAL STAFF". I was excited enough to post a thought ;) I actually do have 2 questions for you if it's okay.
    Is it only me or ԁoes it look as if like a
    few of the commentѕ look as if they aгe coming from brain dead іndіviduals?
    :-P And, іf уou are wrіting on othеr onlinе soсial sіtes,
    I'd like to follow everything new you have to post. Could you list the complete urls of all your public sites like your twitter feed, Facebook page or linkedin profile?

    Also visit my page :: escorts nyc

  3. If you desire to grow your knowledge simply keep
    visiting this web site and be updated with the newest news update posted here.

    Feel free to surf to my site; landing page design

  4. Unquestіonably believe that which you stated.
    Your favorite reason seemed to be on the nеt the ѕіmpleѕt thіng to bе aware оf.
    I say to you, I definitely get irked whilе
    pеople consideг ωorгies that thеy plainlу dο nоt knοw about.
    You managed tο hit the nail upon thе tοp anԁ also ԁefinеd out the whole thing
    without having side effect , people can takе а sіgnаl.
    Will liκely bе back to get more. Thanks

    Feel freе to ѵisit my web ѕite: new york escort service